Skip to content
AI Visibility Observatory · Italian tourism

Italy/Villages/Toscana

Villages · Toscana

01The places

Most named places in Toscana

From this category's comparison questions on the region: how many answers propose each place as a destination. Places named only as a reference ("near Florence") do not count. Each category has its own questions, so the same place can rank differently from one category to another. At equal presence, the place the AI names first more often comes first. The arrow marks places where we also measure hotels.

  1. 4MontepulcianotownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.68%+8
  2. 7San Quirico d'OrciatownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.52%+8
  3. 11MontefiorallevillageHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.36%+16
  4. 12CortonatownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.33%+8
  5. 13SovanavillageHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.28%+14.7
  6. 14PoppitownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.25%+2.7
  7. 15Bagno VignoniresortHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.24%−4

Hotels measured inAnghiariBargaCampiglia MarittimaChiusiCortonaGreve in Chianti; Montefioralle Manciano; Montemerano MontaioneMontalcinoMontepulcianoMonteriggioniPienzaPitiglianoSan GimignanoVolterra

Engine by engine

The top ten places: in how many answers each engine suggests them. Read each percentage on its own: out of 100 answers, how many name that item. An answer usually names more than one, so the total is above 100.

PlaceAll enginesChatGPTCopilotGeminiGrokPerplexity
Pienza 80%+2.7100%47%93%93%67%
San Gimignano 75%−5.367%67%87%93%60%
Pitigliano 69%−1.367%53%67%87%73%
Montepulciano 68%+880%73%53%80%53%
Monteriggioni 57%+1280%33%67%60%47%
Volterra 56%+840%67%60%73%40%
San Quirico d'Orcia 52%+893%0%53%87%27%
Anghiari 48%−473%27%27%47%67%
Barga 45%+1280%13%20%53%60%
Montalcino 41%−453%33%13%93%13%
02Who tells the story

Who tells this destination's story

Every time AI answers about Toscana it cites sources. When it cites a middleman instead of the official site, the destination is told by those who profit from it.

Out of 100 cited sources

  • Tourism promotion sites24%
  • Hotel1%
  • OTA11%
  • Other sources63%

Other sources, 63%: of which

Item by item, out of all cited sources: together they add up to the other sources' share. Next to each, the most cited sites.

  • Travel blogs13%Earth Trekkers · Tenute del Cerro · DoveVado
  • Private tourism portals11%Toscana.info · Discover Tuscany · Visit Italy
  • Newspapers and magazines8%Corriere della Sera · Idealista · Firenze Made in Tuscany
  • Maps and apps7%Google Maps
  • Institutions and associations6%Italia.it · Ministero della Cultura · I Borghi più belli d'Italia
  • Attractions and activities6%MAEC Cortona – Museo dell'Accademia Etrusca e della Città di Cortona · Musei di Volterra · Musei San Gimignano (sangimignanomusei.it)
  • Unclassified4%Chianti.com
  • Social and video4%YouTube · Instagram · Facebook
  • Guidebooks and encyclopedias3%Touring Club Italiano · Wikipedia · Lonely Planet Italia
  • Transport and services2%Boscolo
  • Real estate and holiday homes1%

Site by site, engine by engine

Across the category questions in Toscana, except those about hotels: in how many answers AI cites a tourism promotion site as a source. The first row is the site covering the region most.

Tourism promotion sitesAll enginesChatGPTCopilotGeminiGrokPerplexity
Visit Tuscany regional52%−1.373%0%48%46%95%
Monteriggioni A.D. 1213 s.r.l. (Comune di Monteriggioni) municipal2%+0.88%2%<1%0%0%
Comune di Sangimignano municipal2%+196%0%0%0%2%
Visit Chiusi municipal2%−0.22%<1%4%<1%<1%
Comune di Pitigliano municipal1%−0.23%4%0%0%0%
Comune di Chiusi municipal1%+0.894%3%0%0%0%
Comune di Cortona municipal1%±00%7%0%0%0%
Pienza Welcome municipal1%−0.866%0%0%0%0%
03The sources

How many answers include tourism promotion sites and hotels

Across the category questions in the region, except those about hotels: the share of answers citing at least one tourism promotion site, and the share citing a hotel's website.

Tourism promotion sites
62%
of answers cite at least one tourism promotion site −0.6
Hotel
7%
of answers cite a hotel's own site −2.6
OTA
34%
of answers cite an OTA −1.9
Other sources
82%
of answers cite guides, media, blogs +2.6

As a share of the wave's answers.

Direct site vs OTAs

Out of 100 citations of hotel sites and OTAs, how many go to the hotel's own site and how many to an intermediary (Booking, Expedia, Tripadvisor, Google Hotels). Tourism promotion sites and other sources are left out.

  • Hotel site11%
  • OTA89%

Engine by engine

How many answers of each engine cite a tourism promotion site and a hotel's own site.

Tourism promotion sitesHotel
ChatGPT82%<1%Copilot37%11%Gemini50%13%Grok46%2%Perplexity95%6%

For comparison: OTAs

The intermediaries AI cites instead of tourism promotion sites and hotels: Booking, Tripadvisor, Expedia, Google Hotels.

  1. 1Tripadvisor22%−1.9
  2. 2Expedia12%+0.5
  3. 3GetYourGuide5%−5.9
  4. 4To Tuscany2%−1.62
  5. 5Agoda2%−0.6
  6. 6Viator2%−5.42
  7. 7Google Hotels2%−52
  8. 8Evendo2%+1.3
04The questions

The questions · Toscana

The questions we ask every month, each backed by a real Google search. Under each: the places AI names most, and how many answers cite a tourism promotion site or a hotel's website.

3 questions · their keywords add up to 636,780 Google searches a yearGoogle Ads volume for the exact keyword, sum of the last 12 months. It measures how often this phrase is searched, not how famous the place is.

EN

what are the most beautiful villages in Tuscany?

Search: tuscany villages · 608,100 Google searches a year

  1. 1Pienza100%
  2. 2San Gimignano100%
  3. 3Pitigliano88%

Tourism promotion sites 48%Hotel 4%

IT

quali sono i borghi più belli in Toscana?

Search: borghi toscana · 27,000 Google searches a year

  1. 1Pitigliano100%
  2. 2Montepulciano96%
  3. 3San Gimignano96%

Tourism promotion sites 64%Hotel 0%

IT

dove dormire in un borgo in Toscana?

Search: albergo diffuso toscana · 1,680 Google searches a year

  1. 1Pienza56%
  2. 2San Quirico d'Orcia44%
  3. 3Castellina in Chianti28%

Tourism promotion sites 16%Hotel 36%

05The answers

What AI answers, in full

One question, and one answer from each engine. Highlighted names are the ones we count; below the text, the cited sources.

We asked

«what are the most beautiful villages in Tuscany?»

ChatGPT · gpt-6

Tuscany is full of extraordinary hilltop villages, medieval towns, winding cobblestone streets, flower-covered stone houses and vineyards stretching across the countryside. Some look almost like they haven't changed in 500 years.

If I were choosing the most beautiful villages in Tuscany, these would be at the top of my list.

12 most beautiful villages in Tuscany

1. Pienza – the romantic Renaissance village

One of the most beautiful

A UNESCO-listed historic centre overlooking the Val d'Orcia. Beautiful little streets, Renaissance architecture, artisan shops and breathtaking countryside views.

Don't miss: Via dell'Amore and the panoramic terrace overlooking the valley.

2. San Gimignano – the medieval Manhattan

Famous for its medieval towers, stone buildings and spectacular skyline. It feels like stepping into another century.

Don't miss: Piazza della Cisterna and the views from the town walls.

3. Montepulciano – elegant and cinematic

A gorgeous hilltop town with grand palaces, atmospheric alleys, wine cellars and sweeping vineyard views.

Don't miss: Piazza Grande and a traditional wine cellar.

4. Bagno Vignoni – a village with a thermal pool

One of Tuscany's most unusual and enchanting places. Its main square is an enormous historic thermal-water pool.

Don't miss: The atmospheric central square, especially early in the morning.

5. Monticchiello – a postcard-perfect little village

Tiny, peaceful and incredibly picturesque. Stone houses, narrow lanes and some of the most beautiful views in the Val d'Orcia.

Don't miss: Walking along the medieval walls and enjoying the surrounding countryside.

6. Cortona – romantic views over the countryside

An atmospheric hilltop town with terracotta rooftops, charming restaurants, historic churches and spectacular views towards Lake Trasimeno.

Don't miss: Piazza della Repubblica and the sunset views.

7. Pitigliano – the dramatic village carved into rock

Perhaps one of the most visually spectacular places in Tuscany. Its medieval buildings rise directly from enormous volcanic tufa cliffs.

Don't miss: The panoramic viewpoint outside the historic centre.

8. Sorano – a hidden medieval gem

A magical village surrounded by dramatic ravines, ancient stone buildings and lush greenery. Much quieter than the famous Tuscan destinations.

Don't miss: The medieval fortress and the atmospheric old streets.

9. Volterra – ancient and atmospheric

An ancient Etruscan town with medieval architecture, imposing stone buildings and a wonderfully authentic atmosphere.

Don't miss: Piazza dei Priori and the ancient Roman theatre.

10. Barga – a beautiful village in northern Tuscany

A charming medieval village surrounded by the mountains of the Garfagnana. Its colourful buildings and mountain scenery make it quite different from southern Tuscany.

Don't miss: The cathedral and its spectacular mountain views.

11. Anghiari – a perfectly preserved medieval village

A beautiful fortified village with steep lanes, ancient stone buildings and a lovely historic centre.

Don't miss: Walking along the main medieval street, Il Borghetto.

12. Monteriggioni – a fairytale walled village

A tiny medieval village enclosed by impressive circular walls and towers. It is one of the most recognisable medieval landscapes in Italy.

Don't miss: Walking along the defensive walls and exploring Piazza Roma.

My personal top 5 for sheer beauty

If the goal is to experience the most magical, romantic Tuscany, I'd rank them:

Rank Village What makes it special
1 Pienza Perfect Renaissance beauty
2 Pitigliano Dramatic, almost surreal setting
3 Monticchiello Authentic, peaceful Tuscany
4 San Gimignano Iconic medieval skyline
5 Bagno Vignoni Unique thermal-water square

The most beautiful area: Val d'Orcia

If you have time for only one part of Tuscany, I would choose the Val d'Orcia.

I'd combine:

  • Pienza
  • Monticchiello
  • San Quirico d'Orcia
  • Bagno Vignoni
  • Montepulciano
  • Montalcino

These places are relatively close together and make a wonderful road trip. The countryside between them is just as beautiful as the villages themselves.


One final tip: Visit in May, June, September or October for beautiful light, lovely countryside and generally more pleasant conditions for exploring.

You can also explore the official Visit Tuscany guide to 30 beautiful villages.

If you'd like, I can put together a 3-day road trip through the most beautiful and romantic villages in Tuscany, including scenic roads, hidden gems and the best places to stay.

The map cards ChatGPT shows
Name Score Category Address Phone
Pienza ⭐ 4.6/5 (817) Attraction Pienza, Tuscany, Italy -
Monticchiello ⭐ 4.6/5 (187) Attraction Monticchiello, Tuscany, Italy -
San Quirico d'Orcia ⭐ 4.5/5 (1139) Attraction San Quirico d'Orcia, Tuscany, Italy -
Bagno Vignoni ⭐ 4.5/5 (1101) Attraction Bagno Vignoni, Tuscany, Italy -
Montepulciano ⭐ 4.8/5 (163) Farmstay Montepulciano, Tuscany, Italy -
Montalcino ⭐ 4.6/5 (218) Castle Montalcino, Tuscany, Italy -

Cited sourcesVisit TuscanyPienza Welcome

The engine's original text, without links. Other answers to the same question may differ: that is why we ask it several times.

The rest of this page is free

Leave us your email: we send you a link and the whole observatory opens up, this page and every other one. No password.

We use your email to give you access and send you sign-in links. Details in the privacy notice.