Skip to content
AI Observatory · Italian tourism

Italy/Villages/Toscana

Villages · Toscana

01The places

Most named places in Toscana

From the region's comparison questions: how many answers propose each place as a destination. Places named only as a reference ("near Florence") do not count. The arrow marks places where we also measure hotels.

  1. 5Montepulcianotown61%±——
  2. 9San Quirico d'Orciatown47%±——
  3. 10Bagno Vignoniresort37%±——
  4. 10Cortonatown37%±——
  5. 13Poppitown24%±——
  6. 13Sovanavillage24%±——
  7. 15Montefiorallevillage23%±——

Hotels measured inAnghiariBargaCampiglia MarittimaChiusiCortonaGreve in Chianti; Montefioralle Manciano; Montemerano MontaioneMontalcinoMontepulcianoMonteriggioniPienzaPitiglianoSan GimignanoVolterra

Engine by engine

The top ten places: in how many answers each engine suggests them. Percentages don't add up to 100: each one says in how many answers that item appears, and one answer names more than one.

PlaceAll enginesChatGPTCopilotGeminiGrokPerplexity
San Gimignano 75% ±— —67%67%67%87%87%
Pienza 75% ±— —73%60%73%93%73%
Pitigliano 72% ±— —67%67%60%100%67%
Volterra 64% ±— —47%73%47%73%80%
Montepulciano 61% ±— —73%47%33%87%67%
Anghiari 53% ±— —60%40%33%87%47%
Montalcino 53% ±— —53%47%7%87%73%
Monteriggioni 48% ±— —60%27%40%87%27%
San Quirico d'Orcia 47% ±— —67%0%27%87%53%
Bagno Vignoni 37% ±— —53%13%13%80%27%
02Who tells the story

Who tells this destination's story

Every time AI answers about Toscana it cites sources. When it cites a middleman instead of the official site, the destination is told by those who profit from it.

Out of 100 cited sources

  • DMO20%
  • Hotel2%
  • OTA13%
  • Other sources65%

Other sources, 65%: of which

Item by item, out of all cited sources: together they add up to the other sources' share. Next to each, the most cited sites.

  • Travel blogs16%Earth Trekkers · Bon Traveler · Un Veneto in Viaggio
  • Maps and apps15%Google Maps · Pelago · Komoot
  • Private tourism portals11%Toscana.info · Tuscany Planet · Borghi di Toscana
  • Newspapers and magazines7%Firenze Made in Tuscany · 10cose · Corriere della Sera
  • Social and video4%YouTube · Facebook · Instagram
  • Attractions and activities4%MAEC Cortona – Museo dell'Accademia Etrusca e della Città di Cortona · Lamole
  • Transport and services2%Ekiros
  • Guidebooks and encyclopedias2%Touring Club Italiano · Wikipedia
  • Unclassified2%Chianti.com · visitchiusi.it
  • Institutions and associations2%I Borghi più belli d'Italia · Ministero della Cultura
  • Real estate and holiday homes<1%
  • Hotel listings<1%

DMO by DMO, engine by engine

Across the category questions in Toscana, except those about hotels: in how many answers AI cites a DMO site as a source. The first row is the DMO covering the region most.

DMOAll enginesChatGPTCopilotGeminiGrokPerplexity
Visit Tuscany regional58% ±— —94%0%54%65%77%
Italia.it national13% ±— —39%0%15%2%9%
Monteriggioni A.D. 1213 s.r.l. (Comune di Monteriggioni) municipal3% ±— —7%3%<1%<1%4%
Comune di Cortona municipal2% ±— —2%6%0%0%0%
Comune di Pitigliano municipal1% ±— —4%3%0%0%0%
Comune di Sangimignano municipal1% ±— —6%0%0%0%0%
Comune di Campigliamarittima municipal1% ±— —4%0%2%0%0%
Parchi della Val di Cornia park authority<1% ±— —0%4%<1%0%0%
03The sources

How many answers include DMOs and hotels

Across the category questions in the region, except those about hotels: the share of answers citing at least one DMO, and the share citing a hotel's website.

DMO
64%
of answers cite at least one DMO ±—
Hotel
12%
of answers cite a hotel's own site ±—
OTA
35%
of answers cite an OTA ±—
Other sources
70%
of answers cite guides, media, blogs ±—

out of 1,400 answers

Engine by engine

How many answers of each engine cite a DMO and a hotel's own site.

DMOHotel
ChatGPT97%0%Copilot22%4%Gemini57%22%Grok65%6%Perplexity77%28%

For comparison: OTAs

The intermediaries AI cites instead of DMOs and hotels: Booking, Tripadvisor, Expedia, Google Hotels.

  1. 1Tripadvisor18%±——
  2. 2Expedia11%±——
  3. 3Google Hotels6%±——
  4. 4To Tuscany6%±——
  5. 5GetYourGuide4%±——
  6. 6Agoda4%±——
  7. 7Viator3%±——
  8. 8Civitatis2%±——
04The questions

The questions · Toscana

The questions we ask every month, each backed by a real Google search. Under each: the places AI names most, and how many answers cite a DMO or a hotel's website.

EN

what are the most beautiful villages in Tuscany?

Search: tuscany villages · 608,100 Google searches a year

  1. 1Pienza100%
  2. 2San Gimignano96%
  3. 3Pitigliano92%

DMO 72%Hotel 4%

IT

quali sono i borghi più belli in Toscana?

Search: borghi toscana · 27,000 Google searches a year

  1. 1Anghiari100%
  2. 2Pitigliano100%
  3. 3San Gimignano100%

DMO 48%Hotel 0%

IT

dove dormire in un borgo in Toscana?

Search: albergo diffuso toscana · 1,680 Google searches a year

  1. 1Pienza28%
  2. 2Radda in Chianti28%
  3. 3San Gimignano28%

DMO 32%Hotel 56%

05The answers

What AI answers, in full

One question, and each engine's answer on the first of the 5 runs. Highlighted names are the ones we count; below the text, the cited sources.

We asked

«what are the most beautiful villages in Tuscany?»

ChatGPT · gpt-5-6

Tuscany has an almost absurd number of beautiful borghi (hilltop villages), so “most beautiful” is subjective. But if you're looking for the places that combine architecture, landscape, atmosphere, and that quintessential Tuscan feeling, these are excellent choices. The regional tourism board itself highlights many of them among Tuscany's standout villages.

🌿 My shortlist

  1. Pienza - best for classic Val d'Orcia beauty
    A tiny Renaissance town surrounded by the rolling hills of Val d'Orcia. The historic center was designed as an "ideal city" in the 15th century, and the surrounding landscape is UNESCO-listed.
    Don't miss: the views from Via dell'Amore and Via del Casello.

  2. San Gimignano - best for medieval architecture
    Famous for its medieval towers-13 remain today-and an exceptionally preserved historic center. It's a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
    Don't miss: Piazza della Cisterna and the view from Torre Grossa.

  3. Pitigliano - most dramatic
    This is the one that makes you stop and stare: houses seem to grow directly out of a huge tuff-rock cliff. It's known as “Little Jerusalem” because of its historic Jewish heritage.
    Don't miss: seeing it from the road as you approach-the panorama is spectacular.

  4. Montepulciano - best for wine + views
    A beautiful Renaissance hill town surrounded by vineyards and the Val di Chiana. It's also the home of Vino Nobile di Montepulciano.
    Don't miss: Piazza Grande and one of the historic underground wine cellars.

  5. Montemerano - most romantic/underrated
    A tiny medieval village in southern Tuscany with stone lanes, flower-filled balconies and fortified walls. It has a wonderfully intimate atmosphere.

  6. Anghiari - best for an authentic medieval feel
    Built dramatically along a steep ridge, with narrow lanes, arches, stone buildings and expansive views over the countryside. It's officially included among Italy's Borghi più belli.

  7. Montalcino - best for wine-country scenery
    A hilltop medieval town surrounded by vineyards, particularly famous for Brunello di Montalcino. The views across the Val d'Orcia are superb.

  8. Monteriggioni - best tiny fortress village
    Rather than a sprawling town, Monteriggioni is essentially a beautifully preserved medieval walled settlement, making it particularly atmospheric.

  9. Sovana - best for quiet, ancient Tuscany
    Tiny and atmospheric, with medieval buildings and important Etruscan archaeological remains nearby. It's a good alternative if you want somewhere much quieter than San Gimignano.

  10. Barga - best mountain setting
    In northern Tuscany, Barga sits against the Apuan Alps. Its compact medieval center culminates at the cathedral with views across the mountains.

🗺️ If you only have 2-3 days

I'd concentrate on Val d'Orcia rather than trying to cover the whole region:

Pienza → Monticchiello → Bagno Vignoni → Montalcino → San Quirico d'Orcia

San Quirico d'Orcia and Bagno Vignoni are particularly good additions for the scenery and atmosphere.

And if you have time for one more dramatic detour, go south to Pitigliano + Sovana + Montemerano.

For pure postcard scenery: Pienza / Val d'Orcia
For medieval atmosphere: San Gimignano
For dramatic scenery: Pitigliano
For romance and quiet: Montemerano
For wine: Montepulciano + Montalcino

If you're starting from Florence, I can also map out a 1-day, 2-day, or 3-day Tuscan village road trip with driving times and the best viewpoints.

Cited sourcesVisit Tuscany

The engine's original text, without links. Other runs of the same question may answer differently: that is why we run it 5 times.