Skip to content
AI Visibility Observatory · Italian tourism

Italy/Villages/Umbria

Villages · Umbria

01The places

Most named places in Umbria

From this category's comparison questions on the region: how many answers propose each place as a destination. Places named only as a reference ("near Florence") do not count. Each category has its own questions, so the same place can rank differently from one category to another. At equal presence, the place the AI names first more often comes first. The arrow marks places where we also measure hotels.

  1. 5Castiglione del LagotownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.35%+9.3
  2. 13CorcianotownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.19%+2.7
  3. 14OrvietotownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.17%−2.7
  4. 15Vallo di NeratownHotels not measured: Google searches for staying here fall below the set's minimum threshold (1,000 a year), so we ask no hotel questions.15%+9.3

Hotels measured inBevagnaGubbioMontefalcoNorciaOrvietoPacianoPanicaleRasigliaSchegginoSpelloTodiTorgianoTrevi

Engine by engine

The top ten places: in how many answers each engine suggests them. Read each percentage on its own: out of 100 answers, how many name that item. An answer usually names more than one, so the total is above 100.

PlaceAll enginesChatGPTCopilotGeminiGrokPerplexity
Bevagna 65%+5.373%33%80%87%53%
Montefalco 63%−2.767%40%73%93%40%
Spello 61%+480%33%60%87%47%
Gubbio 44%−1.347%27%20%80%47%
Castiglione del Lago 35%+9.340%0%33%60%40%
Panicale 35%+13.367%27%7%47%27%
Trevi 33%+10.733%53%7%40%33%
Norcia 32%+427%40%20%47%27%
Paciano 27%±020%27%20%40%27%
Todi 27%−13.333%27%7%53%13%
02Who tells the story

Who tells this destination's story

Every time AI answers about Umbria it cites sources. When it cites a middleman instead of the official site, the destination is told by those who profit from it.

Out of 100 cited sources

  • Tourism promotion sites12%
  • Hotel2%
  • OTA13%
  • Other sources74%

Other sources, 74%: of which

Item by item, out of all cited sources: together they add up to the other sources' share. Next to each, the most cited sites.

  • Newspapers and magazines18%Corriere della Sera · Idealista · 10cose
  • Travel blogs12%Tenute del Cerro · Viaggi e Ritratti · Lorenzo Taccioli
  • Private tourism portals9%Bella Umbria · Italia-Italy.org · Orvietoviva
  • Institutions and associations8%Italia.it · I Borghi più belli d'Italia · Chiesa di Todi
  • Social and video7%YouTube · Facebook · Instagram
  • Attractions and activities6%La Consolazione E.T.A.B. · Duomo di Orvieto · CoopCulture
  • Unclassified4%Secret Umbria · Corso di Avviamento alla Direzione d'Orchestra
  • Guidebooks and encyclopedias3%Touring Club Italiano · Wikipedia · Lonely Planet Italia
  • Transport and services3%Exploring Umbria · Telepass - Moveo · FS Bus Italia
  • Maps and apps3%Google Maps
  • Real estate and holiday homes1%

Site by site, engine by engine

Across the category questions in Umbria, except those about hotels: in how many answers AI cites a tourism promotion site as a source. The first row is the site covering the region most.

Tourism promotion sitesAll enginesChatGPTCopilotGeminiGrokPerplexity
Umbria Tourism regional25%−3.354%0%16%2%53%
Comune di Foligno municipal4%+3.31410%0%0%1%10%
Comune di Torgiano municipal3%+0.74%0%6%0%6%
Comune di Paciano municipal3%+1.8106%9%0%0%0%
Live Orvieto municipal2%±00%9%0%1%0%
Comune di Spello municipal2%+0.29%0%0%0%0%
Comune di Spello municipal2%±00%8%0%0%1%
Visit Bevagna municipal2%±04%3%0%1%0%
03The sources

How many answers include tourism promotion sites and hotels

Across the category questions in the region, except those about hotels: the share of answers citing at least one tourism promotion site, and the share citing a hotel's website.

Tourism promotion sites
38%
of answers cite at least one tourism promotion site −6.2
Hotel
9%
of answers cite a hotel's own site +0.2
OTA
34%
of answers cite an OTA −2.7
Other sources
83%
of answers cite guides, media, blogs −0.2

As a share of the wave's answers.

Direct site vs OTAs

Out of 100 citations of hotel sites and OTAs, how many go to the hotel's own site and how many to an intermediary (Booking, Expedia, Tripadvisor, Google Hotels). Tourism promotion sites and other sources are left out.

  • Hotel site13%
  • OTA87%

Engine by engine

How many answers of each engine cite a tourism promotion site and a hotel's own site.

Tourism promotion sitesHotel
ChatGPT66%2%Copilot39%10%Gemini18%29%Grok6%2%Perplexity64%1%

For comparison: OTAs

The intermediaries AI cites instead of tourism promotion sites and hotels: Booking, Tripadvisor, Expedia, Google Hotels.

  1. 1Tripadvisor30%−2.4
  2. 2Expedia11%−1.8
  3. 3Agoda4%+0.9
  4. 4Viator2%−2.41
  5. 5GetYourGuide2%−3.61
  6. 6Winalist2%−43
  7. 7To Tuscany<1%±–new
  8. 8Vrbo<1%+0.4
04The questions

The questions · Umbria

The questions we ask every month, each backed by a real Google search. Under each: the places AI names most, and how many answers cite a tourism promotion site or a hotel's website.

3 questions · their keywords add up to 19,500 Google searches a yearGoogle Ads volume for the exact keyword, sum of the last 12 months. It measures how often this phrase is searched, not how famous the place is.

EN

where to stay in a historic village in Umbria?

Search: albergo diffuso umbria · 1,830 Google searches a year

  1. 1Bevagna68%
  2. 2Montefalco60%
  3. 3Spello52%

Tourism promotion sites 0%Hotel 32%

IT

quali sono i borghi più belli in Umbria?

Search: borghi umbria · 15,980 Google searches a year

  1. 1Bevagna100%
  2. 2Spello100%
  3. 3Montefalco96%

Tourism promotion sites 0%Hotel 0%

IT

dove dormire in un borgo in Umbria?

Search: albergo diffuso umbria · 1,690 Google searches a year

  1. 1Scheggino40%
  2. 2Montefalco32%
  3. 3Spello32%

Tourism promotion sites 24%Hotel 32%

05The answers

What AI answers, in full

One question, and one answer from each engine. Highlighted names are the ones we count; below the text, the cited sources.

We asked

«where to stay in a historic village in Umbria?»

ChatGPT · gpt-6

If you're looking for somewhere truly atmospheric in Umbria, I'd choose a medieval hilltop village with a small boutique hotel or restored palazzo, rather than a conventional hotel in a larger town.

Umbria is wonderful for this: stone lanes, ancient town walls, tiny piazzas, wine bars, olive groves and beautiful countryside.

Here are my favourite places to consider.

6 beautiful historic villages to stay in

1. Spello— prettiest village atmosphere

My top pick

Beautiful flower-filled medieval streets, stone houses, little restaurants and wonderful views. Romantic but still lively enough to enjoy evenings out.

Where to stay: Agriturismo il Bastione— historic 14th-century building among olive groves, just outside the village.

Best for: romance, wandering, restaurants and atmosphere.


2. Castello di Postignano— most magical

Most atmospheric

An entire medieval village beautifully restored, with stone houses, narrow lanes, art spaces and restaurants. It feels like stepping into another century.

Where to stay: Castello di Postignano Relais— rooms and suites spread throughout the historic hamlet.

Best for: a romantic escape, peace and something genuinely special.


3. Panicale— quiet and elegant

A gorgeous little hilltop village overlooking Lake Trasimeno. Less touristy, with lovely views, historic architecture and a relaxed Italian atmosphere.

Where to stay: Rastrello Boutique Hotel— a beautifully restored palazzo with contemporary interiors.

Best for: slow travel, food, wine and beautiful scenery.


4. Saragano— luxury village retreat

A tiny medieval hamlet surrounded by vineyards and olive groves. Particularly appealing if you want to escape and relax.

Where to stay: Aethos Saragano— restored village accommodation, beautiful pool and excellent food.

Best for: luxury, relaxation and countryside.


5. Paciano— authentic and peaceful

A small, beautifully preserved medieval village near Lake Trasimeno. Perfect if you want to experience a quieter side of Italy.

Where to stay: Antico Sipario Boutique Hotel— intimate accommodation in a restored medieval palazzo.

Best for: authenticity, tranquillity and intimate boutique hospitality.


6. Campello Alto— hidden medieval gem

A tiny fortified village perched above the Umbrian valley. Beautiful views, historic buildings and a wonderfully secluded feeling.

Where to stay: Relais Borgo Campello— a restored medieval hamlet with castle and monastery accommodation.

Best for: getting away from everything.

Where they are


My recommendation

I'd narrow it down to these three:

  • Spello: if you want a beautiful village where you can stroll to dinner and enjoy the atmosphere.
  • Castello di Postignano: if you want the experience of staying in a restored medieval village.
  • Panicale: if you want something quieter, sophisticated and less discovered.

A question to help me find the perfect place

Are you imagining:

  1. A romantic boutique hotel in a medieval village, with restaurants and cafés within walking distance.
  2. A luxury restored hamlet or castle, with a pool, beautiful views and excellent food.
  3. An authentic little Italian village, less touristy, with a lovely B&B or historic guesthouse.

And roughly what nightly budget do you have in mind?

I can then narrow this down to some particularly beautiful places to stay, rather than just the better-known hotels.

The map cards ChatGPT shows
Name Score Category Address Phone
Spello ⭐ 4.7/5 (528) Cultural landmark Spello, Umbria, Italy -
Castello di Postignano ⭐ 4.8/5 (167) Tourist attraction Località Postignano, 21, 06030 Sellano PG, Italy +39 0743 788911
Panicale ⭐ 4.7/5 (775) Restaurant Panicale, Umbria, Italy +39 075 837151
Saragano ⭐ 4.9/5 (149) Winery Saragano, Gualdo Cattaneo, Umbria, Italy +39 331 152 5414
Paciano ⭐ 4.7/5 (76) Attraction Paciano, Umbria, Italy -
Campello Alto ⭐ 4.3/5 (6) Castle Campello Alto, Campello sul Clitunno, Umbria, Italy -

The engine's original text, without links. Other answers to the same question may differ: that is why we ask it several times.

The rest of this page is free

Leave us your email: we send you a link and the whole observatory opens up, this page and every other one. No password.

We use your email to give you access and send you sign-in links. Details in the privacy notice.